A Bigger Vision Than Our Own Holy Huddle

Chances are, you are/were a Boy Scout or know someone who was in Boy Scouts or know someone whose brother was in Boy Scouts. For the past century, Boy Scouts of America (BSA) has shaped the life of thousands of American boys. Now, that may be changing in some Christian circles. Why? Back in May, the Boy Scouts of America changed a 103-year-old policy to allow members and leaders of any sexual orientation.

Christians and other conservatives were astonished, despite the fact that the BSA still maintains “a longstanding policy against any discussions of sexuality within the organization.” People who have generations of Boy Scout blood flowing through their veins have walked away. In response, an alternative scout group was organized and launched earlier this month. Trail Life USA was founded “to be the premier national character development organization for young men which produces Godly and responsible husbands, fathers, and citizens.” The unashamedly Christian group coined the motto, “Walk worthy.”

Many of us are inclined to applaud and say, “Way to stand up for biblical values!” Or, “Thank you for protecting our sons!” Or even, “What a testimony to the truth of God’s design for sexuality!”

And yet I wonder: Who will shine like stars among a crooked generation? Who will proclaim the excellencies of Christ to those who are not yet God’s people? Who will be Christ’s witnesses to the ends of the earth? Who will live radical, holy life as exiles so as to provoke the question, “Where is your hope?”

You see, it is all-to-easy to retreat and start our own Christian version of Boy Scouts or anything else for that matter. There is little support for that kind of vision in the Bible. In fact, I find zero support for it.

What if our went deeper than biblical “values”? What if it aimed higher than security and protection for children? What if our vision was a dangerous and complex one without simple formulas? What if our vision was to image the One who left his sanitary home to live among filthy sinners? What if our vision was to image the One who ate and drank with sinners, not to burden them, but to give them a glimpse of the freedom of grace? What if our vision was to image the One who did not simply call people to repent, but loved them toward repentance. 

This One–Jesus of Nazareth, the Son of God–did not ask for his Father to take his people out of the world (John 17:15). No, he commanded his people to be salt and light in the world. That is very hard to do if you willingly run away from those who actually need salt and light. The apostle Paul was obviously familiar with Jesus’ teaching, for he writes about this very thing in 1 Corinthians 5. He says, “I wrote to you in my letter not to associate with sexually immoral people–not at all meaning the sexually immoral of this world, or the greedy and swindlers, or idolaters, since then you would need to go out of the world. But now I am writing to you not to associate with anyone who bears the name of brother if he is guilty of sexual immorality or greed, or is an idolater, reviler, drunkard, or swindler—not even to eat with such a one” (vv. 9-10, emphasis added).

The admonition, then, is not “flee from the gays in the world.” It is, “If a Christian brother (or sister) is not living in accordance with his confession (i.e. not repenting of sin), then you must not allow him to remain in the secure confines of the local church, therefore giving him false assurance that all is well with his soul.”

Creating a holy huddle may produce moral, disciplined, and respectful young men. But it will hardly produce men who know how to relate to lost people and saturate a culture with the gospel. How do I know this? Because I am recovering holy huddle member. Though not as a scout, I lived a life of seclusion and avoidance of “bad people.” During high school and college, I avoided “sinners” like the plague so I would not become like them and because, honestly, I felt uncomfortable around them. Now, as an almost 29-year old pastor, I am unlearning my tendency to avoid messy, sinful, lost people.

You see, the only way we will transform pockets of culture and see people repent of sin and believe in Jesus is if we saturate those pockets with the gospel. Retreating and avoiding will only confirm what non-Christians have believed for years: Christians only want to escape this earth and go to heaven, so they create their own little cultural bomb shelters while they wait for Jesus to return. 

Homosexuality is wrong. Period. No ifs, ands, or buts. But taking your ball and going to another court will not draw the Boy Scouts or anyone else to Jesus. In fact, it will only push them farther away. Have you ever yelled at a blind person for walking into a parked car? Probably not. What did you do? You had compassion on her, walked up to her, grabbed her hand, and tenderly, yet firmly said, “I will show you the way.” The same is true for helping the spiritually blind.

So Christian scouts, if you are reading this, the BSA is full of sinners who need Jesus, just like you. You belong to Jesus. You know Jesus. Declare his excellencies to those who don’t belong to him and don’t know him yet. Do it up close. On their turf. In their troops. It is by no means safe and sanitary. But Jesus’ mission to purchase your redemption was not safe or sanitary either. As his ambassadors, it should not be any different for us.

One reply on “A Bigger Vision Than Our Own Holy Huddle” Could you be confused about Trail Life USA – it is more open to youth than BSA (who continues to exclude people of no-faith or “atheists”) TLUSA is designed to be an outreach ministry as much as discipleship (and my roles (plural) as a Christian adult range from raising my children in the Word (Dt 6:1-9,, mentoring other young men (titus 2, and being a witness to the lost, least, & last.) We recognize that just about all of the boys and young men who participate start with unregenerate hearts (just being raised in a Christian home doesn’t provide salvation; therefore, we are making disciples close to home to begin with, and if we do it correctly, we raise them to be effective witnesses, too). I am presently an active BSA scoutmaster, and have been simultaneously collaborating with TLUSA to better understand what they’re doing instead of listening to the media reports who put their own spin on everything they author. I’m also concerned that you spare no frustration for other groups like Cadets, Service Brigade, Royal Rangers, who went into the huddle bunker generations prior to TLUSA becoming reality — are they not equally culpable for dissuading generations of Christians into the supposed bunker of isolation? How about “christian basketball leagues” — should they be disbanded as a huddle program? Close all private church schools and ban homeschooling? Where does it stop? Thanks for the interesting post — clearly it got me pondering.


Comments are closed.